Lawyers for five Guantanamo Bay detainees demanded Tuesday that the Guantanamo War Crimes Tribunal lift the gag order that prohibits their clients from speaking about the torture and systematic mistreatment they faced after coming into custody of the U.S. government and during their incarceration at the offshore prison.

The lawyers also called for their clients’ death penalty charges—on accusations they were involved with the 9/11 attacks—to be dropped because of the torture and silencing they have faced.

“If the United States government wants to prevent these men from talking about the horrific things that happened to them, you can’t have it both ways,” declared defense attorney Cheryl Bormann, who represents Yemeni inmate Walid bin Attash, at Tuesday’s pre-trial hearing. “You can’t gag somebody and then kill them.”